In an effort to mitigate the impact of inflation on its residents, California initiated the Middle-Class Tax Refund (MCTR) program. This one-time payment, orchestrated by Governor Gavin Newsom in collaboration with state lawmakers, was distributed between October 2022 and September 2023.
Table of Contents
How the Payments Work
The MCTR payments ranged from $200 to $1,050, determined by the recipients’ reported Adjusted Gross Income (AGI). Here’s a breakdown of how the amounts were allocated:
- AGI of $500,001 or more: No payment.
- AGI of $250,001 to $500,000: $400, plus an additional $200 for dependents.
- AGI of $150,000 or less: $700, potentially increasing to $1,050 with dependents.
Distribution Method
To ensure fairness, the funds were distributed based on the recipients’ last names, with payments starting in October for early alphabetical listings and concluding in September for later ones. The payment method varied:
- Direct Deposit: Funds were deposited directly into recipients’ bank accounts.
- Prepaid Debit Card: Funds were loaded onto prepaid debit cards, distributed by Money Network, a third-party vendor contracted by the state. These cards can be used until April 30, 2026, after which they will be deactivated.
Unclaimed Funds
Despite the program’s extensive reach, about 624,000 debit cards, containing at least $125 million, remain unclaimed. This is concerning because these unclaimed benefits likely belong to residents in urgent need of financial assistance.
Reasons
Several valid reasons account for the unclaimed benefits, primarily revolving around issues with the prepaid debit cards:
- Scams and Fraud: Many recipients were targeted by scams. Reports emerged of cards being used fraudulently, leaving legitimate users without their funds. For instance, Jeannia from Petaluma recounted that her card was used fraudulently for purchases she didn’t make. Similar stories have surfaced, with users finding their cards partially or fully drained before they could use them.
- Poor Customer Support: Affected users who contacted Money Network for assistance often encountered unhelpful responses, including instances where calls were abruptly disconnected. This lack of support further complicated the issue for victims of fraud.
EDD Fraud Scandal
The situation has drawn comparisons to the 2020 Employment Development Department (EDD) fraud scandal. State Assemblyman Jim Patterson highlighted the severity, suggesting it might be worse due to the nature of the fraud. He noted that the scammers could remotely drain accounts without having the physical card but somehow possessing the PIN numbers, potentially through dark web activities.
The MCTR program was a well-intentioned effort to support Californians amid rising inflation. However, the distribution issues, particularly with the prepaid debit cards, have left many without the intended relief. Ensuring that these funds reach those in need is crucial, and addressing the fraud and support challenges is imperative for the success of such programs in the future.
FAQs
What is the Middle-Class Tax Refund (MCTR) program?
The MCTR program is a one-time payment initiative by California to help residents cope with inflation.
How were the payments distributed?
Payments were distributed via direct deposit or prepaid debit cards, based on recipients’ last names.
Why are some benefits unclaimed?
Issues such as scams, fraud, and poor customer support have led to many prepaid debit cards remaining unclaimed.
What should I do if my card was used fraudulently?
Contact Money Network immediately and report the issue to the Franchise Tax Board for further assistance.
When do the prepaid debit cards expire?
The prepaid debit cards must be used by April 30, 2026, after which they will be deactivated.
