Hidden in old penny jars and forgotten coin collections across America, some of the most valuable coins in numismatic history may be waiting to be observed.
While most pennies are worth just one cent, these nine extraordinary coins have achieved legendary status, with some valued at nearly $10 million. Their stories involve minting errors, historical quirks, and fascinating circumstances that turned ordinary cents into collector’s gold.
Table of Contents
1943 Copper Penny
One of the most famous rare pennies, the 1943 copper penny, shouldn’t exist at all. During World War II, the U.S. Mint switched from copper to zinc-coated steel to conserve materials for the war effort.
However, a few leftover copper planchets from 1942 were mistakenly used, resulting in around 40 copper pennies being minted.
Only 12 authentic 1943 copper pennies are known to exist today. Their rarity and historical significance have driven prices sky-high. In 2021, one sold privately for just over $11 million, making it one of the most valuable pennies ever.
1944 Steel Penny
Following the 1943 copper penny, another error occurred in 1944. That year, the Mint returned to using copper, but a few steel planchets from the previous year accidentally made it into production.
Even rarer than the 1943 copper penny, only seven 1944 steel pennies are known to exist. One recently sold for $10.7 million, with collectors valuing it as the “reverse error” of the 1943 copper cent.
1958 Double Die Penny
The 1958 Double Die penny is one of the most dramatic printing errors in U.S. coin history. A misalignment during the die hubbing process created a noticeable double image on Lincoln’s portrait.
Only three examples are known to exist, making it rarer than the well-known 1955 Double Die penny. One of these recently sold for just under $10 million in a private transaction.
1909 VDB Matte Proof
Regular 1909 VDB pennies are common, but the matte proof version is an entirely different story. Shortly after production began, Victor David Brenner’s initials (VDB) were removed from the design, but a few matte proof specimens with the initials were made for presentation.
Only four authentic examples survive today. One of these coins sold for $10.2 million in 2023, making it one of the most desirable early Lincoln pennies.
1872 Indian Head Penny
The 1872 Indian Head penny from the San Francisco Mint is a numismatic mystery. Records show a large mintage, but only a few specimens exist today.
Some believe the coins were melted down, while others speculate that a ship carrying them sank. Only five authenticated examples are known, with one selling for $10.5 million.
1867 Aluminum Pattern Penny
In 1867, the U.S. Mint experimented with aluminum for coin production. These pattern coins were never intended for circulation, but a few escaped into private collections.
Only three are known to survive, with one recently selling for $10.3 million. Their status as experimental coins makes them especially valuable to collectors.
1922 No D Penny
The 1922 No D penny resulted from a worn-out die at the Denver Mint that erased the “D” mint mark. While many 1922 pennies have faint “D” marks, true No D pennies have none at all.
Only five high-quality examples exist, with one recently selling for $10.1 million. Since this was the only year Philadelphia didn’t produce pennies, this error is particularly sought after.
1943-S Copper Penny
Like its Philadelphia counterpart, the 1943-S copper penny from the San Francisco Mint is a wartime error. Even rarer, only six authenticated specimens exist.
A recent private sale saw one example reach $10.4 million, with experts predicting its value will continue to climb due to its extreme scarcity.
1794 Starred Reverse Penny
The 1794 Starred Reverse penny is one of the earliest and most mysterious U.S. coin varieties. Tiny stars were punched between the reverse lettering, but the reason remains unknown.
Only four examples exist today. One sold for $10.2 million, and its status as a first-year issue continues to captivate collectors.
FAQs
How do I know if I have a rare penny?
Check the date, mint mark, and any unusual features like errors.
What makes a penny valuable?
Rarity, historical significance, condition, and minting errors.
Where can I sell a rare penny?
You can sell rare coins through auctions, dealers, or online marketplaces.
How much is a 1943 steel penny worth?
Most are worth a few cents, but rare errors can be worth thousands.
Are there still rare pennies in circulation?
Yes, but finding one is extremely rare due to collectors and metal detectors.
